By Lia Avagyan
Nine Armenian media organizations have called on the government to withdraw a draft law introducing minimum compensation for insult and defamation, warning that the changes could expose independent news outlets to financially damaging lawsuits and undermine press freedom.
The proposed changes, published by the Ministry of Justice on Monday, would require courts to award compensation worth no less than roughly $2,800 for insults and twice as much for defamation.
Under existing law, courts have discretion to determine compensation based on the circumstances of each case. The law sets maximum amounts of roughly $8,300 for insults and roughly $16,600 for defamation.
The proposed changes would therefore restrict judges’ ability to award smaller amounts. Critics argue that substantial compensation could threaten media outlets’ financial standing.
In a statement published on Wednesday, the nine organizations argued that the existing practice is consistent with rulings by the European Court of Human Rights and Armenia’s Constitutional Court, which require judges to consider the financial capabilities of media organizations when setting penalties.
The organizations warned that the amendments could provide politicians, public officials, and other prominent individuals a way of exerting financial pressure on journalists, particularly when criticism is interpreted as insult or defamation.
The Ministry of Justice argues that existing compensation rules are disproportionate to the severity of harm caused by insults and defamatory statements. The ministry says stronger compensation mechanisms are needed, while acknowledging that not every instance of insult or defamation should automatically result in financial compensation.
The organizations have called for the proposal to be withdrawn, followed by open consultations with media representatives. They also urged the authorities to submit the amendments to the Council of Europe and other international institutions for expert assessment.
The statement was signed by nine organizations, including the Committee to Protect Freedom of Expression, Yerevan Press Club, Media Initiatives Center and Asparez Journalists’ Club.












